Government 'inconsistent' in energy policy, says report

  • Published: 01 August 2008 10:15
  • Last Updated: 01 August 2008 11:51
  • Reader Responses  

Britain does not need to build major new power stations to fill the projected 'energy gap' if it meets its renewable targets, according to a new report by energy consultants Pöyry, commissioned by green groups WWF and Greenpeace.

The report says that if the British government meets its EU renewable energy tagets, and its own plans to reduce demand through energy efficiency, then new coal or gas power stations power would not be needed before 2020.

Head of Climate Change at WWF-UK, Keith Allott said, "This report should be good news for the Government. If it gets real on its targets on renewables and energy efficiency then we can keep the lights on, reduce our reliance on expensive fossil fuel imports and dramatically cut our carbon emissions.

"But a green light to Kingsnorth would at a stroke undermine the Government's other policies on climate change and Gordon Brown's promise of a clean energy revolution."

According to the report, the new coal-fired station at Kingsnorth would not be needed to plug the 'evergy gap' expected by the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform with the additional renewables.

The report went on to say that if the government met its wind power targets, then it alone would be able to supply the power needed, even taking into account the very few days when there is little or no wind. 

Greenpeace's head of climate and energy, Robin Oakley said, "Coal is the single most climate-wrecking form of electricity generation. The only reason anyone is even considering building Britain's first coal fired power station in decades is the claim that we need it to keep the lights on. E.ON's spin machine and the Labour government have teamed up to hoodwink the public into believing it, but this report busts their argument wide open."

The government's current commitment is to 15% of our total energy from renewable sources by 2020, with as much as 35% of Britain's electricity coming from renewables.


Please note: In order to post a response you need to be registered on the site. You can register here.

Reader Response

Greenpeace's sums of the country's energy needs do not add up. Neither have they taken any account of the transmission requirements (and losses) nor synchronisation or phase lag.

Those of us who built the major power stations understand several important factors: -

We know how a power station works; we know that they are forty years old; we appreciate that plant needs more maintenance with age; we know the plants will eventually wear out; we know they will need repalcing sooner rather than later; we also know that a 1 MW windmill does not go far towards the output of a 500 MW turbo-alternator let alone the 1,600 MW Unit that EDF are building at Flammanville.

Those of us who designed and built the power stations are now in their late seventies to nineties, so there is little that we can do about it. But we do not like the indecision which, probably not in our lifetimes, will inevitable lead to the lights going out - which is back to 1947!